BIS Countdown: Sir John Grieve - In the eye of the storm
As deputy governor of the Bank of England, Sir John Gieve was in the centre of the worst financial crisis for a century. What has hindsight revealed and what are his views on the subsequent regulatory shake-up?
Sir John Gieve was deputy governor of the Bank of England until 2009 and has been at the centre of the UK government for the past 25 years. As deputy governor of the Bank of England, he was a key player in the battle to stabilise the banking system in the face of the worst financial crisis for a century, to protect the economy by reducing interest rates to their lowest level on record, and to forge new policies globally to prevent it happening again. Post caught up with him ahead of his appearance at the British Insurance Summit to find out his views on the banking crisis, future regulation and the insurance industry’s voice.
How culpable was the Financial Services Authority for the banking crisis in the UK?
The FSA has been very open about its failings in the run up to the crisis — more so than the many other institutions involved whose failures were at least as great. It failed to supervise some of the banks effectively — notably Northern Rock, Royal Bank of Scotland and Halifax Bank of Scotland. More generally, it failed to appreciate how vulnerable the growth in banking leverage and dependence on wholesale funding had made not just individual institutions but the whole financial system. However, it was not alone in that; it was part of a wide consensus among banks, regulators, central banks and commentators that failed to see the cliff edge approaching, and believed that markets were generally self balancing and that, provided inflation was kept on a stable low path, financial market storms could be managed without great damage to the wider economy. And finally, of course, the root of the crisis was in the US housing and securities market not in the UK, so it shouldn’t take most of the blame.
Did it need a major overhaul or would it had been best to leave it be with some tweaks?
Both regulation and monetary policy have needed a major overhaul. First, we need to give a lot more attention to the network of institutions and the systemic connections — as opposed to the risks of individual institutions — and, second, we need to develop new instruments to dampen the credit cycle. These are the two sides of so-called ‘macro-prudential policy’. In addition the FSA needed to tighten up supervision of major institutions. I don’t think that strictly required the FSA to be split up and that will give rise to transitional difficulties, but the proposed system in which the bank takes on prudential supervision and the rest goes to a new Financial Conduct Authority has been made to work elsewhere.
Insurers have complained about being unjustly penalised in the regulatory shake up, having played little or no part in the UK recession. Do you sympathise or agree with their argument?
I agree that insurers were not generally central to this crisis — although AIG played a very important role in building the pack of cards, which was the sophisticated securitised markets. Of course, the tougher approach to supervision was bound to rub off from banks to insurers and other parts of the system. However, I am not sure that swapping the FSA for the Bank as prudential supervisor will be much disadvantage to them. There is a risk that the Bank may give insurers less attention than the banks, but I doubt whether that is seen as a penalty.
Do you think insurers and brokers have
always had a proportionately quieter voice in regulatory matters compared to other financial services sectors?
It is true the big banks have had a stronger voice than the insurance industry in London. That partly reflects the role of London as a centre of international banking and partly the central role of bank lending in the economic cycle. Insurance tends to dominate the news only when there are disasters — natural or made by the industry. Keeping a low profile may be a good sign.
What are your views about the planned replacements for the FSA?
Have any major opportunities been lost in the shake up? I don’t think any balls have been dropped yet. The governance in the Bank looks a bit elaborate and confusing but there is probably time to simplify that. Of course, much remains to be decided — particularly in the market conduct side.
UK insurers are currently planning for one of the biggest overhauls in living memory with the introduction of Solvency II. With this in mind do you think the regulatory shake up is ill-timed? Not least because the FSA appears to be struggling to hold on to its best staff in this area?
This was the biggest recession and financial crisis of our lifetimes and changes do need to be made. There are bound to be uncertainties and difficulties in the transition, but the best way of minimising those is to press ahead and clarify how it is all going to work — including who will have jobs where in the new set.
Do you understand the protests of UK brokers about the level and calculation of Financial Services Compensation Scheme levies, which for some have escalated 700-fold in the wake of the payment protection insurance scandal, a scandal which has predominantly been a banking issue?
Of course I understand the complaints of the insurance brokers but I also understand the cries of anguish from the banks that did not get into trouble and are now paying for their competitors that did. And I don’t think the taxpayer is eager to step in to meet the costs. The right answer here is probably to have a pre-funded scheme with premia related to risk. That way the most risky firms pay at least part of the costs of their failure. However, pre-funding has never been popular with the industry and it is not possible until this huge bill is paid off.
Where do you think the prime regulatory challenges will be for insurers and brokers moving forward under the PRA and FCA?
On the prudential side the big immediate changes are Solvency II and the way the Bank approaches its task. Overall, I suspect the Bank of England will be more risk averse than the FSA has been, at least until recently, so insurers can expect more challenges and questions. We will also see a more challenging and analytical approach on market regulation where the new FCA is likely to put insurers and others in retail markets under renewed scrutiny. The FSA has been criticised in the past for devoting too much attention to retail conduct of business, but I don’t think it was particularly effective in that arena. The FCA may be tougher, particularly on the retail side.
Do you think London will retain its pre-eminent role as an insurance market, or is there a danger over-regulation will drive other companies abroad?
I am expecting globalisation to continue with further consolidation in finance and a growing concentration of wholesale markets. London starts with the huge advantage of its inherited position in the insurance and banking markets. It could no doubt spoil that by mistakes on regulation or tax but they would have to be big and sustained. The key on regulation will be what happens in Brussels. So far — and partly as a result of the UK’s efforts – it has been content generally to move with the wider international consensus in Basel, the International Organisation of Securities Commissions, and so on, and there are advantages to business in having greater regulatory harmonisation. But there is always pressure to change to a more hostile approach.
What do you think the insurance industry could do to have more of a voice when it came to regulatory decision makers?
I don’t think you should crave the limelight — leave that to the banks and independent financial advisors. The Association of British Insurers, for example, has always struck me as pretty influential and effective in the UK in a low-key way. I guess the biggest challenge is to spread that influence in Brussels, Strasbourg and globally.
For more information on the British Insurance Summit.
Only users who have a paid subscription or are part of a corporate subscription are able to print or copy content.
To access these options, along with all other subscription benefits, please contact info@postonline.co.uk or view our subscription options here: https://subscriptions.postonline.co.uk/subscribe
You are currently unable to print this content. Please contact info@postonline.co.uk to find out more.
You are currently unable to copy this content. Please contact info@postonline.co.uk to find out more.
Copyright Infopro Digital Limited. All rights reserved.
As outlined in our terms and conditions, https://www.infopro-digital.com/terms-and-conditions/subscriptions/ (point 2.4), printing is limited to a single copy.
If you would like to purchase additional rights please email info@postonline.co.uk
Copyright Infopro Digital Limited. All rights reserved.
You may share this content using our article tools. As outlined in our terms and conditions, https://www.infopro-digital.com/terms-and-conditions/subscriptions/ (clause 2.4), an Authorised User may only make one copy of the materials for their own personal use. You must also comply with the restrictions in clause 2.5.
If you would like to purchase additional rights please email info@postonline.co.uk