This law report has been contributed by national law firm Berrymans Lace Mawer
Minio-Paluello v Commissioner of Police of The Metropolis (2011) (Queen’s Bench Division —
16 December 2011)
Queen's Bench Division, 16 December 2011
The claimant and her friend, Taimour Lay, were involved in a pro-Palestinian demonstration on 9 January 2009 in the vicinity of the Israeli Embassy in London.
The claimant and Lay were among a group of protestors on the pavement who attempted to force their way past a line of police officers in order to join cyclists protesting in the road. Lay was warned by the police that he would be arrested for obstructing the highway and to prevent a breach of the peace if he did not stay on the pavement.
Lay then went into the road and was lawfully arrested. The claimant tried to frustrate that arrest by holding onto Lay and, as a result, they, and the officers, fell to the ground.
An officer, PC Pelham, used force to lock the claimant’s arm behind her back. He then lifted her up and in the process she sustained a fracture to her upper arm. The police said that the force used by PC Pelham was necessary to complete the arrest of Lay (section 117 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984) and to prevent a criminal offence being committed (section 3 of the Criminal Law Act 1967) and in any event the force used was in self defence and/or in defence of fellow officers.
The court appears to have accepted that some force would have been justified. However, the method used by the officer was dangerous and neither reasonable nor proportionate. The court was guided by both the medical evidence, which said that the force used must have been “considerable” to cause such an injury, and also the evidence of an officer responsible for safety training, who said that police are not taught to use the arm lock technique when a suspect is on the ground. Therefore, the claimant was entitled to damages for assault and general damages were awarded in the sum of £11 500.
Daniel West, BLM London
Sounded a good plan, Exec Team Visit to our wonderful claims team in Morecambe, bit of a ‘Back to the Floor’ & dish out some Easter Eggs. Lovely. So how did I end up with these & having to wear them home on the train? Thanks @helenidle @AXAUK @AXA_Broker #BunnyEars pic.twitter.com/cNd80WnRPd— David Williams (@AXADavidW) April 17, 2019
- Claims Apprentice 2019: Episode 6 - The interviews
- Blog: To grow, insurers must hit the open road
- Blog: The changing landscape of identity theft
- Analysis: How can insurers offset the increased repairer costs associated with Adas?
- Motor premium upturn 'on the horizon' after modest Q4 price cuts: Confused and WTW
- Ministry of Justice launches consultation into the future provision of medical reports
- Cytora becomes UK's best funded insurtech with £25m Series B raise