Skip to main content

Are modern methods of construction changing insurance?

Post Podcast: John Nicholls at HSB Engineering, Douglas Brown at Renovation Underwriting, Gary Holmes at Commercial Express, and Tony Derbyshire of Crawford Contractor Connection

How modern methods of construction are challenging insurers is explored in the latest Insurance Post Podcast.

 

The growing use of modular and offsite construction, pods, green roofing, structural insulated panels, 3D printing and timber-frame construction is changing not only how buildings are put together, but also how insurers assess and respond to losses.

In the latest Insurance Post podcast, Gary Holmes, head of schemes development at Commercial Express, said increasing adoption meant developers and lenders expect insurers to understand the risks associated with construction methods that are designed to be faster and cheaper than traditional methods.

More data rather than less is advantageous in this space.
John Nicholls

One of the biggest challenges for insurers is the limited amount of historical claims data available to assess and price modern methods of construction risks.

John Nicholls, construction leader at HSB Engineering, was asked whether he had enough claims data to confidently price the risk in 2026.

“No, is the short answer,” he said. “The return on claims is low in this space, but when they happen it can be pretty nasty. They can distort the claims pattern.

“More data is highly advantageous when we are looking to adapt coverages, widen coverages and tune rating. More data rather than less is advantageous in this space.”

Holmes said data relating to modern construction methods was still in its infancy and called for clearer records of the materials being used and agreed on property.

That lack of information can also create problems when a claim occurs, according to Tony Derbyshire, head of managed repair at Crawford Contractor Connection, who said his team often only discover that a modern method of construction was used when they arrive at the loss.

Traditional v modern

Derbyshire shared how the speed and efficiency of factory-based construction can amplify problems when something goes wrong.

He explained how traditional construction provided more opportunities for errors to be identified and corrected during the building process.

It is only often when these properties are lived in that these problems become evident and then you’ve got a sizeable loss.
Tony Derbyshire

“When things went wrong on site when building traditional, you noticed them straight away or you had a clerk of works, back in the day, that would check on the quality,” he said. “Those mistakes and errors and inconsistencies would be put right at that time.

“With modern methods, because the big advantage is the speed and sustainability, and parallel working that this brings, it also brings risk in terms of the volumes of the panels and pods made in factories.

“If they are all well-constructed and well-designed then great, but if there is one error that can be repeated multiple times… It is only often when these properties are lived in that these problems become evident and then you’ve got a sizeable loss.”

The scale of those losses can create a particular challenge for insurers and their repair networks.

“From a repair perspective they are clearly not something we can just send a man in a van to. They become a construction project in their own right,” Derbyshire noted.

Water ingress

Douglas Brown, managing director at Renovation Underwriting, said reducing the amount of construction work taking place on site could reduce certain risks, but warned the connections between modules and the quality of materials could introduce others.

Brown said: “Where you have heavy penetration of water, particularly in these modular designs, it is really difficult to get a hold of that. Getting it out of walls when they are constructed of heavy insulation is incredibly difficult. That creates more total losses than it does repairable claims.

“The other thing you need to take into account here is a lot of the manufacturers are relatively inexperienced and not necessarily in business when these claims occur, so you are then trying to cobble together something that will do.

“There is a price to pay in terms of – dare I say – what is fashionable.”

Brown’s comments highlight another issue for insurers: the ability to identify who is responsible for a defect and whether the relevant manufacturer or contractor will still be available when a claim emerges.

Nicholls said that where the contractor was responsible for the full supply chain, this could be advantageous from an underwriting perspective, particularly where manufacturers subsequently cease trading.

The experts argue that insurers need more information not only about how MMC properties are manufactured and constructed, but also about how long different materials and systems are expected to last.

Understanding those lifespans could help insurers establish whether particular innovations are delivering genuine performance benefits or whether design and aesthetics are taking precedence over long-term functionality.

For claims teams, meanwhile, the challenge is understanding whether a property can be repaired economically or whether the nature of its construction means rebuilding is the more realistic option.

Click the player button to hear the podcast or download the episode via your podcast provider of choice – including Apple, Google, Spotify and Audible – simply by searching for Insurance Post.

Only users who have a paid subscription or are part of a corporate subscription are able to print or copy content.

To access these options, along with all other subscription benefits, please contact info@postonline.co.uk or view our subscription options here: https://subscriptions.postonline.co.uk/subscribe

You are currently unable to copy this content. Please contact info@postonline.co.uk to find out more.

Big Interview: Mark Huxley, Foil

As he prepares to succeed Laurence Besemer at Foil, Mark Huxley sets out his plans to raise the organisation’s profile and influence across the insurance market.

AI claims handling: Are insurers listening to customers?

As artificial intelligence accelerates claims processing and improves fraud detection, Neil Heasman, operations director at Charles Taylor Assistance, argues human expertise remains essential to building trust and supporting customers through complex claims.

Are insurers doing enough to share intelligence to combat fraud?

The insurance industry has invested heavily in tackling fraud, but with criminals increasingly operating across sectors and borders, Association of British Insurers senior policy adviser for general insurance, Jonathan Purvis, says a more connected approach to sharing intelligence is needed.

Diary of an Insurer: Intact’s Carolyn Mackenzie

A week of international travel, complex claims, broker meetings and talent development – with family life, a fractured sacrum and a hoverboard mishap – keeps Carolyn Mackenzie, vice president of complex claims and specialty at Intact Insurance, on her toes.

Ifed on why fight against fraud must focus on the fraudster

Colin Jemide, protect officer at the Insurance Fraud Enforcement Department of City of London Police, explains why intelligence sharing, prevention and collaboration are key to disrupting organised insurance fraud without creating unnecessary barriers for genuine policyholders.

Most read articles loading...

You need to sign in to use this feature. If you don’t have an Insurance Post account, please register for a trial.

Sign in
You are currently on corporate access.

To use this feature you will need an individual account. If you have one already please sign in.

Sign in.

Alternatively you can request an individual account here