Skip to main content
Insurance Post

Europe: Emerging markets supply chain risks

Kaspersky map showing location of mobile malware infections around the world

Increasing use of emerging markets as global suppliers could pose challenges for insurers

 Hungry for growth, rich with resources and often offering substantial cost savings, there is much to recommend emerging markets as suppliers. But, for insurers, they also pose challenges.

For starters, there is limited cover available, thanks to volatility and uncertainty in these areas. According to Volker Muench, global practice group leader, Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty: "The challenge for insurers is to ensure they can provide insurance while also being aware of the accumulation of risk which the supply chain can pose.

"Reinsurers are focused on this area, as are rating agencies, which want to be sure insurers are adequately managing their level of risk."

While this may be acting as a stumbling block to growth, there is no doubt that demand for - and awareness of - the need for cover, is rising.

European Insurance Forum debate

At the recent European Insurance Forum in Dublin, Jacob Rosengarten, chief enterprise risk officer for XL Group, spoke about the interconnected global risks facing businesses - and these included the rise of developing markets.

He said rapid economic growth and urbanisation have combined to create instability, and these conditions "are now becoming more prominent, especially where supply chain risk is concerned. Developing markets are playing a larger role in producing items such as computer chips that developed markets need, and any disruption has a global ripple effect."

There is certainly more talk about supply chain cover, but coverage is often bespoke and the biggest risks may only be covered via captives - a costly and inflexible option for some businesses.

Business interruption

Meanwhile, earlier in the year, the AGCS Risk Barometer survey also highlighted business interruption/supply chain as the biggest global risk, taking precedence over natural catastrophes such as earthquake and flood.

Muench comments: "For many companies, greater reliance on emerging economies for products such as component parts or raw materials has increased [the risks associated with business interruption].

"They may be aware of this, but insurance solutions are not readily available or not purchased."

AGCS is one of the relatively few insurers that provides supply chain risk insurance. Muench says while this coverage should be seen as core for some industrial clients "in some cases, companies are not adequately covered because they have just purchased traditional property and casualty. They do not have the correct BI limits or cover for contingent risks."

When the supply chain is disrupted, the need for cover is drawn sharply into focus.

Reliance on a key supplier

Back in 2011 the flood in Thailand created a shortage of key components in the computer industry. Over 1000 factories were affected and subsequent insurance claims were said to be around $20 billion.

Muench adds: "An incident at a single plant can create huge fall-out. An example occurred last year at a Chinese factory that produces almost one-sixth of chips used to store data in PCs and mobile devices. This has an impact on shipments, and pushed up prices. Although manufacturing began again, it showed how vulnerable companies can be when they rely on one key supplier."

Lloyd's syndicate Kiln sees huge potential in supply chain insurance and active underwriter Paul Culham says: "Currently there has been too much emphasis on property assets, when for some businesses, they face more risk from financial losses linked to their supply chains."

He adds the emphasis on property insurance and related business interruption is unsuited to the supply chain and with emerging markets, issues such as political risk and trade disruption may have far more relevance.

"Interdependence is one of the most important factors now and clients need to be able to map all their supply chain risks. Risk managers are expecting insurers to innovate and to cover all the risks, from the shipping of goods to cyber liability. There is a real need to innovate."

But it is not just profit that can suffer from a supply chain crisis, he says: "Companies that rely on minerals, often supplied from Africa and Latin America, should also think about who they are buying from - are they satisfied with the supplier's track record on ethics, and could reputational issues ensue if they are shown to be using a dubious supplier's materials in finished goods?"

Developing local teams

Analyst Gartner's survey of 35 of its top 100 global supply chains found the problem businesses most frequently encounter when expanding into emerging markets is coping with differing rules and regulations, with the need to develop local teams the second biggest issue.

Poor transport infrastructure, patchy communications and inconsistent supply of local products are all obstacles companies must overcome, so doing due diligence on any local enterprises firms go into partnership with is crucial to ensure they can deliver what is promised.

The survey said carrying out supplier risk assessment on all stages of a supply chain can help businesses ensure there are no weak links in the process. Operating overseas will come with challenges not associated with domestic markets, so more intensive assessment is required.

Simon Burtwell, head of EY's UK general insurance practice, comments: "I believe the availability of appropriate supply chain insurance is one of the big problems facing companies. There are relatively few insurers supplying contingent business interruption and they have not kept pace with the increasing amount of outsourcing to low cost economies."

He agrees that even if businesses have cover, they may have insufficient limits and that some smaller firms in particular may need guidance on issues such as reputational risks.

"The rush to outsource has, of course, brought savings, but at the same time, we have seen a number of cases where suppliers have not stood up to scrutiny. There is a growing realisation that companies may well need to rely on their risk managers more and fully understand who is doing work for them."

Breaking out of siloes

The availability of supply chain insurance will also be dependent on knowledge and risk management.

Muench says it is positive that risk managers in many cases are working in more joined up ways. "For example, they will have an in-depth knowledge of logistics. Being in a silo will not result in the required levels of awareness.

"There is now far more understanding about the risks of relying on one major supplier and of too much outsourcing. Companies need strong business continuity planning so, for example, they can use alternative methods of transport if necessary."

Supply chain cover where emerging economies are concerned is a relatively new market itself, but as globalisation continues apace, it is very much in the development pipeline.

 

 

 

 

Only users who have a paid subscription or are part of a corporate subscription are able to print or copy content.

To access these options, along with all other subscription benefits, please contact info@postonline.co.uk or view our subscription options here: https://subscriptions.postonline.co.uk/subscribe

You are currently unable to copy this content. Please contact info@postonline.co.uk to find out more.

Most read articles loading...

You need to sign in to use this feature. If you don’t have an Insurance Post account, please register for a trial.

Sign in
You are currently on corporate access.

To use this feature you will need an individual account. If you have one already please sign in.

Sign in.

Alternatively you can request an individual account here